Alternate title: An Emphatic Protest Against the Movie “500 Days of Summer”
On general principle, I have a baseline level of respect for movies that aim to tell an interesting story rather than just pander to the lowest common denominator. Netflix always creates category recommendations for me called “Cerebral Foreign Dramas” and “Thought-Provoking Cultural Documentaries” and I eat it all up, barely pausing to feel the shame inherent in being a stereotype. Independent movies, therefore, are usually somewhat up my alley. But this is an example of an indie movie that hits the same stale notes as, I don’t know, The Notebook or some shit. Just because the female love interest hasn’t had a nose job (she’s so real!) doesn’t mean this is anything but a painfully banal unrequited love caper, albeit one shot on cheaper film. Most of the gestalt of this movie is pure Hollywood, and all the Urban Outfitters garb in the world can’t change that. When the eponymous Summer tells a joke about how she used to be called Anal Girl in high school (due to her organizational skills), there’s a fucking spit take. Spit take = zero cred. It’s just simple math.
It’s impossible to care about the protagonist because he has no discernable gonads whatsoever. I get that he’s supposed to be the sensitive impish hipster type, but even within the realm of sensitive impish hipsters he’s unbearably pathetic. He gets the girl alone numerous times and doesn’t make a move; she asks him outright if he likes her and he says no. Now, I myself would never respond favorably to aggressive courting, but I do expect a man who’s sexually interested in me to, like, show some sexual interest in me. As a female viewer, I felt no sympathy for this socially impotent doofus, nor did I understand why Summer eventually started fooling around with him in the copy room. What of it, Summer?
It’s also not evident why Summer is so entrancing to the protagonist. Aren’t there any other pretty girls in your town who listen to indie rock? In my town, that’s like three quarters of the female population. What’s so special about Summer isn’t really clear, nor is it clear why she has such a bug up her ass about relationships. She becomes distinctly odious when she defends her stance that Ringo is the best Beatle by saying, “Nobody likes him; that’s why I like him.” People who go out of their way to demonstrate how “quirky” they are are perhaps the most insufferable people on earth. These are basically two inscrutable, unlikeable characters who bone for a while (off-camera, no less!) and then stop. Hey, I have an idea, let’s make a movie about them! Or LET’S NOT. And let’s not make the trailer deceptively intriguing, thus causing people to spend their Friday night groaning through this clunker.
And of all of the movie’s flaws, the most fundamental is this: If you spend 500 days wild with infatuation because a girl sings a Smiths lyric while you’re standing in the elevator together, then HOW DOES IT FOLLOW that the music you hear in your head when you think about her is 1) Hall and Oates and 2) “She’s Like the Wind” by Patrick Swayze? I give up.